Fakhteh Luna Zamani’s Speech on Minority Rights in Iran

14 March 2012 - In conjunction with the report of the Special Rapporteur on human rights in Iran to the UN Human Rights Council, the Unrepresented Nations and Peoples Organization (UNPO) and Minority Rights Group International (MRG) hosted a parallel event titled “Minority Rights in Iran.” The event took place in Geneva, Switzerland, and included contributions from minority and NGO representatives. Through this event, UNPO and MRG aimed to draw attention to the human rights situation of ethnic, religious, and linguistic minorities in Iran.

I would like to thank MRG and UNPO for supporting disadvantaged groups all over the world and organizing this event.

It has been an extraordinary year for the Middle East and the Arab world. Civil uprisings against corrupt regimes permeated nearly 20 countries, and these social movements have mesmerized the greater international community. Amidst the deposition of corrupt governments in one of the most volatile regions in the world, Iran’s government has remained in power. With that, its human rights record remains untouched, and the international community continues to be unaware of the status of Iran’s minorities.

I am here to address the issues facing one of these minorities: the Azerbaijani Turks living in Iran, whose fundamental human rights are consistently violated by the government of Iran.

The Azerbaijanis are concentrated in north-western Iran and make up the largest minority in the country. Since the establishment of the Pahlavi regime in 1925, Azerbaijani Turks, and other minorities in Iran, have been subjected to racism and cultural, linguistic, and economic discrimination in law and practice. Farsi continues to be the only language of instruction in the Iranian education system within the multilingual country of Iran. Insufficient language education, combined with systemic disparity, means that many Azerbaijani people cannot escape generational poverty and remain economically and socially stagnant within their communities. The Azerbaijani population has long sought to end socio-economic and cultural inequality and to have the Azerbaijani-Turkish language included as a language of instruction in public schools.

Azerbaijani activists, including human rights defenders, journalists, writers and students who advocate for the rights of their oppressed community, risk frequent human rights violations ranging from arbitrary arrests to death at the hands of Iranian Security Forces. All peaceful demonstrations demanding cultural rights, protesting socio-economic injustice and racism, and calling for the protection of the environment, have been violently suppressed. Scores of people have been arrested. According to Amnesty International, “those who seek to promote Azerbaijani cultural identity and linguistic rights are often charged with vaguely-worded offences such as “acting against state security by promoting pan-Turkism.” Detainees are subjected to psychological and physical torture, which often yields false confessions.

One human rights activist, journalist Sa’id Metinpour, is currently serving an eight-year prison sentence for peacefully campaigning for fundamental rights for his community. Amnesty International calls him a prisoner of conscience.

The assault on Azerbaijani culture, language, and identity by the Iranian state-run media and press is not uncommon. Azerbaijanis are often stereotyped, insulted, and mocked, not only in the workplace and in person, but in the media as well. Since the founding of ADAPP in 2006, my team and I have identified numerous recurring sources of continued racism against Azerbaijanis. First and foremost is the portrayal of Azerbaijanis in Iranian culture and media. In the spring of 2006, the government newspaper Iran Daily published a cartoon that depicted Azerbaijanis as cockroaches. Not only was the comparison insulting and a clear example of state-sponsored racism, but it also implied the need to mass exterminate an entire minority group. Dozens were killed, and scores were arrested after Azerbaijanis took to the streets to protest the racist cartoon. Although the crackdown was brutal, much like the recent measures against the Iranian election protests, it received little attention from the international community.

As in many other parts of the world, women in Iran are victims of violence on a daily basis, but Iran's justice system provides no recourse for them.  Even the little progress towards culturally-inclined respect for women’s rights is hampered by Iran’s sexist and misogynistic legal system. Discriminatory laws in both the Iranian civil and penal codes play a crucial role in empowering men to create a glass ceiling for women who actively campaign to change these laws. In the words of Azerbaijani poet and women’s rights activist, Faranak Farid, “Race, ethnicity, gender, language and culture, social class, religion, place of residence, disability, etc. are factors which create inequality and discrimination. Often, women confront most of these forms of discrimination.” So minority women are victimized twice, as one Azerbaijani women’s rights activist stated, “We are both women and minorities; in the Islamic Republic of Iran, we are doubly accused.” 

Members of the Azerbaijani community, particularly women, also face difficulties in the criminal justice system because of their inability to speak and understand Farsi, the sole official language of Iran. An example of this is the case of Sakine Muhammadi Ashtiani, an Azerbaijani woman who was convicted of adultery and sentenced to death by stoning. Her son and lawyer believed that she did not receive a fair trial. They claim that her confession was acquired under pressure and, because she spoke only Azerbaijani-Turkish, she was unable to effectively communicate her case to her Farsi-speaking interrogators and in court.

In the Persian and Shia Muslim- dominated country of Iran, Azerbaijani religious minorities such as Sunnis, Alevis, Jews, Christians and Bahais face both ethnic and religious discrimination. Discrimination against non-Shia Azerbaijanis by the Iranian government is evidenced in their lack of opportunity to complete higher education, their prevention from establishing religious schools and non-governmental organizations, their difficulty obtaining state positions, and their experiences of discrimination in the Iranian justice system as evidenced by their receiving relatively heavier sentences. 

Reports obtained by ADAPP from Sunni and Alevi communities, show several members of these communities being sentenced to execution after unfair trials largely based on confessions obtained under torture and false documents allegedly prepared by the Ministry of Intelligence and National Security. In 2011, at least six members of the Azerbaijani-Sunni minority group were executed in Urmia Central Prison on accusations of drug trafficking. Another example of an unjust trial is the case of Mehdi Ghasemzadeh’s, a 27-year-old Azerbaijani male, belonging to the Alevi religious minority, who was executed in February 2009, after having been convicted of the charge of “enmity toward God.” Also, reports from Sunni and Alevi communities from the Azerbaijani region show that Iranian officials impose financial hardship on farmers by redirecting water supplies away from their villages and thus exposing their farms to water shortages.

The predominantly Azerbaijani-populated cities of Iran are also being confronted by a pending environmental catastrophe that will result in the drying-out of Lake Urmia, which is situated between West Azerbaijan and East Azerbaijan provinces and is one of the largest salt lakes in the world. In the Azerbaijani cities of Urmia and Tabriz, protest the Iranian Government’s poorly-planned irrigation and damming projects which are starving the lake of fresh water.  A violent police crackdown on Azerbaijani protesters ensued, resulting in scores of injuries, thousands of arrests, and, reportedly, four deaths.

According to a February 2012 United Nations Environment Programmee (UNEP) report, as lake levels decline, the exposed lakebed is left with a covering of salts, making a tremendous salty desert on much of the 400 km² of lost surface area. These salt flats will not support agriculture and inhibit the growth of most natural vegetation. The salts are also susceptible to dispersion by wind and will likely create "salt storms" like the ones that have resulted from the drying of the Aral Sea, located 1,200 km to the northeast of Lake Urmia.

In recent years, the Iranian government has built dams on more than 20 tributaries feeding into the lake. Environmental organizations and experts claim that this damming, coupled with an environmentally damaging bridge linking the cities of Urmia and Tabriz, has reduced the flow of water into and within Lake Urmia, causing the majority of the lake to evaporate.

 The deterioration of Lake Urmia impacts 13 million local inhabitants and the nations of Azerbaijan, Turkey, Iraq, and Armenia. According to Esmail Kahrom, a professor of environmental sciences at the University of Tehran, if Lake Urmia dries up, “six to eight cities will be totally destroyed, covered by layers and layers of salt.”

Ladies and Gentlemen, the plight of minorities in Iran is an issue that rarely receives attention in the international community and media. The international community must bring this issue to light and urge the government of Iran:

To allow education in Azerbaijani Turkish in Iranian schools and allow for the creation of independent media outlets in this language, to release all prisoners of conscience who have been unlawfully arrested for advocating for Azerbaijani linguistic and cultural rights, and for ceasing all arrests and detentions of Azerbaijani rights activists who assemble peacefully and contribute to journals advocating in favour of human rights for Azerbaijanis.

To put an end to socio-economic and cultural discrimination against Azerbaijanis as well as other non-Persian Iranians.

To call on the Islamic Republic of Iran to eliminate discrimination against women and girls and to comply with its international obligations to build gender equality.      

To demand the Iranian authorities to stop the execution of non-Shia Azerbaijanis and other Iranian ethnic and religious minorities sentenced to death in unfair trials based on the confessions obtained under torture.

To urge the Iranian government to allow the Azerbaijani religious minority groups the freedom to fully engage in religious, political and social activities and to end education and job discrimination against them.

Due to the international scope of the Lake Urmia crisis, ADAPP urges intervention and guidance from international organizations, including UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) and the UNEP (United Nations Environmental Programme). We believe that the international community and organizations need to stand with indigenous populations and ethnic minorities to help protect their rights of free speech, assembly, and peaceful protest, along with their rights to access to freshwater for farming and sustenance. 



Related Link: https://www.unpo.org/article/13979