Rouhani in Tabriz: The Controversies of a Visit

Taher Shir Mohammadi – Deutsche Welle Farsi – May 20, 2015

Hassan Rouhani’s visit to Tabriz was overshadowed by the "Tractor Sazi controversy," which dominated the agenda to the extent that longstanding promises, such as the "revival of Lake Urmia and the establishment of a Turkish Language Academy," were sidelined.

On Wednesday, May 20, 2015, as part of his provincial tours, President Rouhani visited East Azerbaijan Province. His trip to Tabriz became one of the most controversial provincial visits due to the "Tractor Sazi incident." A day before his trip, Rouhani instructed Mahmoud Goudarzi, the Minister of Youth Affairs and Sports, to investigate and thoroughly review all aspects of the final match involving the Tractor Sazi football team.

The next day, the Minister of Sports, speaking in Tabriz, acknowledged, “There were issues with the refereeing.” Meanwhile, Azerbaijani representatives in the parliament, including Nader Ghazipour, a member of the Sports Caucus Presidium, demanded a replay of the Tractor Sazi–Naft match.

Welcoming Rouhani with Turkish Slogans

Coinciding with Rouhani’s visit to East Azerbaijan, Iran newspaper, affiliated with the government, published a special issue with the headline: “Şəhriyar Diyarınə Xoş Gəlibsiz!” (Welcome to the Land of Shahriyar!). During his speech at Tabriz’s Takhti Stadium (Bagh Shomal), the President began his remarks in Turkish and recited a poem from Heydar Baba, a famous Azerbaijani work by poet Mohammad Hossein Shahriyar. He praised Azerbaijan as the birthplace of Shahriyar, the "Commander of Words," as well as Parvin E'tesami and Nizami Ganjavi.

Rouhani addressed red-clad fans of the Tractor Sazi football team, responding to chants of “Tractor, Tractor” from 50,000 people. He said, “Tractor Sazi belongs to the people of Iran, and no one can toy with the emotions of Tabriz’s champions.”

The President’s involvement in the "Tractor Sazi issue" drew criticism from local media, who accused the government of neglecting the broader issues facing East Azerbaijan Province.

The regional websites Anaj and Tabriz Bidar criticized the President, stating:
“The President reduced all the province’s issues and challenges to the Tractor Sazi–Naft match and surprisingly used this sports incident for political maneuvering.” They further claimed, “The government is attempting to exploit Tractor Sazi for political purposes.”

Local outlets also lamented that the government had seemingly forgotten its primary purpose in visiting Tabriz, which was addressing the province’s challenges and issues.

Rouhani Did Not Visit Lake Urmia

The People of Azerbaijan Still Hope for the Revival of Lake Urmia

Ahead of Rouhani’s trip, Azerbaijani MPs and local officials, including East Azerbaijan’s Governor Jabbarzadeh, highlighted the need to fulfill "delayed promises." Reza Rahmani, the representative for Tabriz, Azarshahr, and Osku, stated that the people’s most significant demands from the President were the revival of Lake Urmia and the establishment of a Turkish Language Academy.

The day before Rouhani’s visit, First Vice President Eshaq Jahangiri chaired a meeting of the "Lake Urmia Rescue Task Force," warning: “If the Lake’s problems are not resolved, the resulting issues could threaten a part of the country.”

Many local media outlets reminded readers of the President’s promise made during a 2013 trip to Urmia, when he declared: “We will revive Lake Urmia and will not let it dry up. Rest assured, if I assume executive responsibility, reviving Lake Urmia will be on the government’s agenda from day one.”

However, Ali Alilu, the representative for Shabestar, expressed disappointment, stating that while the government initially prioritized Lake Urmia, it had not moved beyond words to take meaningful action.

Some Azerbaijani MPs called on the President to visit the “frontlines of Lake Urmia’s damage” and finally address the concerns of Azerbaijani citizens. Yet, Rouhani did not visit the Lake during his trip to East Azerbaijan. He only briefly mentioned in his speech in Tabriz that the situation of Lake Urmia had improved compared to the previous year.

Two Messages from the People of Tabriz to Rouhani

Karimzadeh, editor-in-chief of the Nasr News website, analyzed President Rouhani’s visit to Tabriz in an interview with Deutsche Welle (Persian). He said:
“The enthusiastic reception from the people of Tabriz for President Rouhani carries two essential messages: the first is that Tabriz stands behind Rouhani, and the people of Azerbaijan have always tried to support his administration. The second message is that the government of prudence [Rouhani’s administration] needs to fulfill the promises it made in 2013 more effectively. President Rouhani reiterated the famous slogan of Tabriz residents, ‘Azerbaijan is awake and supports the revolution,’ multiple times during his speech for this reason.”

However, in his 35-minute speech in Tabriz, Rouhani did not once mention his promise to establish a Turkish Language Academy.

Karimzadeh elaborated on this omission, stating:
“Regarding the establishment of the Turkish Language Academy, it has been decided that instead of a dedicated academy, a ‘Foundation for the Culture, Literature, and Arts of Azerbaijan’ will be launched in the historic house of the late Parvin E'tesami. This foundation will encompass a range of activities that include both those of an academy and various cultural, artistic, and literary programs. While the academy would focus solely on language and literature, this foundation covers all artistic, literary, and linguistic aspects.”

“Rouhani’s Visit Has Nothing to Do with Football”

Hassan Shariatmadari, an expert on Azerbaijan affairs, also analyzed Rouhani’s visit to Tabriz. He said:
“Rouhani’s visit was planned before the recent football incidents and has no direct connection to the Tractor Sazi controversy. Instead, it revolves around long-standing demands such as the revival of Lake Urmia, the establishment of the Turkish Language Academy, and attention to the province’s industrial projects, which have been largely neglected.”

Shariatmadari added that the trip was overshadowed by election-related hype and criticized the administration’s lack of strong commitment to reviving Lake Urmia. He predicted that Rouhani’s visit to East Azerbaijan would not yield significant results, given the unfulfilled promises.

Rouhani’s Silence on the Language Academy

Shariatmadari was also skeptical about the prospects of a Turkish Language Academy. He emphasized:
“The establishment of this academy is an old demand of the people of Azerbaijan and would enrich the language. A serious decision is needed in this regard, which could only come through the liberation of ethnic and national languages in Iran’s centralized and restrictive cultural environment.

So far, under Rouhani’s administration, we have not seen any major signs of such a decision. Perhaps the Azerbaijani people, through their perseverance, might establish a cultural center to produce vocabulary or organize grammar rules. However, whether it will flourish and leave a lasting mark on written Turkish literature depends on how much freedom this language has and its capacity for growth.”

Rouhani also issued orders to launch construction and inaugurate 32 provincial projects as part of his visit to East Azerbaijan.


The link to the original article in Farsi on Deutsche Welle Radio:
روحانی در تبریز؛ جنجال‌های یک سفر